The Pumpkin and the Pie
Yesterday it was still raining. Raining for a week straight! And more getting around in the rain. I had lunch with Em and Vangie, who was in town for a wedding, driving all around the world to coordinate said function. When I got home after another soggy day of out and about, I was greeted with the happy news that my father-in-law was offered a new job, after being unemployed for over a year. Blessings!! To celebrate, I set about making a pumpkin pie. Besides it was cold and dreary outside, what better day to fill the kitchen with warmth and spices.
So, I thought I'd document how to make a pumpkin pie. From the pumpkin itself to the end product.
![]()
You can use an official pie pumpkin, they are slightly richer in texture, but honestly, I can't tell a whole lot of difference between a real pie pumpkin and a typical jack-o-lantern pumpkin, which will be bigger and cheaper, perhaps. Cut up the pumpkin into manageable pieces, piercing the piece with a fork. Bake in a low oven (around 200 degrees) for about two hours, covered with tin foil and a little water in the bottom of the pan. (I've also had success microwaving smaller amounts. Cover with plastic and check every ten minutes until it is tender.) After it has cooled, peel the skin. It may come off easily by just pulling it, but often I have to use a potato peeler to help.
Puree the pumpkin, which can be done easily with a food processor or a handheld blender (my favorite kitchen appliance). (In a pinch I've used a fork to mash it, but the texture isn't as smooth.) There's a lot of water in the pumpkin, so it's good to drain it a little. I always use a paper towel, because it soaks faster. Then you're ready to make the pie.
Recipe
2 eggs
2 cups of pureed pumpkin
1 can of evaporated milk (my Joy of Cooking said I could 3/4 c milk if I didn't have evap. milk, and it's just not the same, I'm sticking to the evap. milk)
1/3 c. packed brown sugar
1/2 c. white sugar
1 tsp cinnamon
1 tsp gr. ginger
1/2 tsp nutmeg
1/4 tsp cloves
(or if you're like me and are a spice fiend, you can throw spices in with abandon. I also use a little cardamom, too)
Mix ingredients. Pour into pie crust. Bake 35-45 min on 350 (until knife or toothpick comes out clean).
Pie crust is very straightforward. It's not as intimidating as people make it out to be. These are measurements for one crust. (So, like if you were making an apple pie and needed a top and bottom, double these measurements.)
1 c. flour, 1/3 c. shortening, enough COLD water to make it stick (start with about 1/4-1/3 c.)
Cut the shortening into the flour with a pastry cutter (or fork, if you don't have one) until it is crumbly. Add water and stir around with fork, until you can form it into a ball. It's important that your water is cold. I often have an ice cube sitting in some before I use it. Roll dough out on a floured surface. If you roll it out on wax paper then when it is rolled out, you can put your pie plate upside-down in the middle of the dough, slide your hand underneath the wax paper, and flip it. That way you don't have to wiggle around with your pastry. Trim and flute the edges. The key to perfect pie crust is
A decorative bonus. Find a leave from outside (unless you think you can freehand one or someother design yourself)--if you get a sturdy one, you can wash it with soapy water first. Cut out the leaf design on the extra pastry you trimmed off the pie. Bake seperately, for about 15 min on 350. After the pie is baked, lay your decoration on top. Voila!
Just call me Martha!!
(Actually the last idea, my mom saw on Martha years ago.)
Comments
Okay, you know I'm hormonal when the leaf touch makes me cry. This entry made me very happy.
Posted by: lynnp | 15.10.05 12:10
Comments
You'll be so proud... I have bought a pumpkin to try this out! Yip! It's actually gonna happen this year!
Posted by: Shannon | 15.10.05 12:19
Comments
Thanks, Diber! My pie pumpkin has been sitting on the countertop for awhile now and I can't wait to try this recipe. I'm a little afraid of making a crust from scratch though. We'll see...
Posted by: Rebecca | 15.10.05 13:34
Comments
aww! that looks soooo good! I wish Tim liked pumpkin pies. Maybe I'll make a sweet potato pie sometime soon...
Posted by: Joanna | 15.10.05 14:34
Comments
You have inspired me. I have never made a pumpkin pie from scrath - meaning from a real pumpkin. I have always relied on the canned pumpkin filling. I need to wait a while to start making pies; memphis has not entered fall, yet. It is 89 degrees today.
Posted by: beth | 15.10.05 14:42
Comments
You can make crust, Rebecca! It's not that hard, I promise!
This looks amazing, Jeannette. I have never made a real, from-scratch pumpkin pie and you just might inspire me to give it a whirl! Actually, I don't think I've ever made pumpkin pie, period. My mom is the pie goddess and I just stay out of her way!
Posted by: kristen | 15.10.05 15:12
Comments
I've never made a pumpkin pie but your's looks so good, I think I'll have to give it a whirl this year. The leaf adds such a unique touch to an ordinary pumpkin pie. Now, I'd like to see you carve one! Yum!
Posted by: Dawn | 16.10.05 02:59
Comments
I've never made a pumpkin pie but your's looks so good, I think I'll have to give it a whirl this year. The leaf adds such a unique touch to an ordinary pumpkin pie. Now, I'd like to see you carve one! Yum!
Posted by: Dawn | 16.10.05 03:00
Comments
Mmm... time for pumpkin things. I'm feeling the need to make a pumpkin cheesecake too, with the yummy ginger-snap crust. =) Wish you were here to help me eat it!
Posted by: Erica | 16.10.05 20:37
Comments
What fun! I am feeling inspired, too. Thanks for this entry. And I love the leaf touch. Am definitely going to have to try that. I've baked only a few pies in the past, but for one that I made for my father's b-day last year, I used a cookie cutter to make the famous (is it still famous?) Philadelphia "LOVE" sculpture to put on the pie's surface.
Posted by: YelloCello | 16.10.05 21:32
Comments
I made pumpkin bread this weekend. Mmmm. . .
Posted by: lynnp | 17.10.05 10:51
Comments
Martha!
Posted by: Sarah Mosley | 18.10.05 08:47
Comments
I have to warn all you pie-bakers out there. You won't be able to go back to canned pumpkin. If you do, you will find out why people say they don't like pumpkin pie. Truth is, they never really had it. So Joanna, go give it a try. If you make sweet potato pie, you can put the 'raw' dough leaf right on top and it bake when you bake the pie, instead of making a separate step out of it. One more thing. I use 1/3 cup of water with a TWO crust, not one, and it is adequately moist. It should be very workable. Yesterday I made EIGHT pie crusts. One would not roll very well so I wadded it up and rolled it out again and it worked great.
If you all have digitals, wouldn't it be fun to see all the pies!! If I had a digital I would show you all my pie crusts and my very messy kitchen! But, alas...... maybe next time I'll beg Jeannette to come over so she can be my photographer. well, we're waxing with verbosity.
Officium vocat, the Mother of pie makers!!
Posted by: mom1 | 18.10.05 08:54
Comments
Well, I never knew how my mom did it with so little water, because I always end up using about 1/3 c. what for one crust. So, I guess you'll have to experiment and find what's right for you.
I agree with my mom...you'll never be able to go back to canned pumpkin. Yucko! (But pumpkin freezes beautifully...you can make 2 c. baggies, and voila!)
Posted by: Jeannette | 18.10.05 09:12